The Discipline Question No One Can Answer

Of all the tough issues parents face, discipline is tops. I had noted this working with parents over the years, but since I started blogging, it’s become really obvious.

No Bad Kids – Toddler Discipline Without Shame” was my first post about discipline, and it’s been read nearly five hundred thousand more times than anything else I’ve written. It’s the post that typically gets the most visits each month, even though it’s been years since I wrote it.

The “No Bad Kids…” post was recently shared (on Facebook and Pinterest) with a new wave of readers, which means a new round of comments. This time they’re mostly about spanking, a practice I strongly advise against. The tone of the comments range from indignant to angry, and although I’ve tried to be patient and measured with my responses, the deep chasm between our perspectives makes a calm discussion nearly impossible. And we can certainly forget about either of us changing each other’s mind — there’s no way that’s going to happen.

But if there’s one valuable thing I’ve learned from blogging, it is that hearing a radically divergent view is the way to a better understanding of theirs and yours, which can then lead to empathy. After avoiding disagreements for most of my life, I’m finally seeing the value in them.

I always end up with the same question for spankers: If you knew with all certainty that spanking was totally unnecessary for raising well-mannered, kind and successful children, would you still do it? If so, why?

I’ve posed this countless times to commenters on my blog and in discussions elsewhere on the web. I’ve been told my question is ridiculous and that I’m ignorant. Still, no one answers. So it has finally occurred to me that I should put the shoe on the other foot and answer the question myself.

If I became convinced that spanking was totally necessary for my children to become well-mannered, kind, successful people, and if there were many studies that seemed to prove that by not spanking I am harming my children, it would still be extremely hard, if not impossible, for me to spank. This might be because my parents didn’t spank, so it’s not in my realm of experience.  Intentionally causing my children pain is abhorrent and completely unimaginable to me.

Believing in the need for spankings would also mean accepting to my core that my parents failed me. They didn’t care enough to do what was right. How could my parents have neglected the tiny, vulnerable me? How could they not do the best thing for me when I know they loved me?

I’d eventually realize that they couldn’t help it. They inherited their parenting practices from their parents (and so on), and none of them could overcome their visceral response not to spank. It’s not that I wasn’t worthy, right? Did I deserve their neglect?

But anyway, I turned out fine, didn’t I?

I would probably continue to rationalize my inability to spank. I’d be comforted reading anti-spanking articles and surround myself with like-minded parents.

But suppose the more I educated myself, the more compelling and convincing the necessity for spankings became. By avoiding them, I was putting my child and our relationship at risk. I might then go to counseling in hopes of breaking the destructive cycle that had been passed down to me. I’d do all within my power to overcome my fear of physically punishing my child. It would still be really tough. But if I committed myself and worked hard enough, I might one day be as courageous as this dad (mentioned in a pro-spanking comment on “No Bad Kids…”):

My dad would sometimes include that “this hurts me more than it hurts you,” and often had tears in his eyes after placing a few firm pats on my butt. 



I share a complete guide to effective non-punitive discipline in my book,  No Bad Kids: Toddler Discipline Without Shame





Please share your comments and questions. I read them all and respond to as many as time will allow.

  1. Dear Janet
    I am sitting here already an hour reading what you posted here and especially reading what all these people wrote.
    I am an orthodox Jewish woman who lives in Israel. I am a mother of 11. My mother died when I was only 4 and my father brought me and my 3 brothers up with so much love and caring.
    My husband came from a very poor family, loving parents but his father would spank him especially for not paying attention to his learning.
    Our eldest son got spanked and I remember being against it and my husband would say “you do not understand it so please don’t mix in”
    I am happy to say that he quickly stopped this and apoligized to my son and always spoke publicly to our other children that the only discipline action that he is very sorry about is when he spanked our oldest son- who really turned out a specially great man- but not due to the spanking for sure.
    As an educational councelor in daycare centers in Israel I teach caregivers EFT to calm down before they reach the peak of nerves. I tell them to tap in front of the kids in their charge and explain “I feel anger and I am going to do something to calm down.”
    This with deep breaths and drinking water is an amazing way to calm down and show the kids that we are normal and there is a way to sooth our nerves.

    Here is to all mothers, caregivers and all people in the universe who are keen on being good parents and better people by showing the children a model of how it is done. Good luck to us all.

  2. When my daughter was younger I tried spanking, it only ever made things immediately much worse. I don’t spank anymore. When I think back to my childhood and the times I was spanked, it was usually when my parents had misunderstood or misjudged me.

  3. Thank you for writing this article, your ability to empathise and your quest to understand is amazing. As a parent who is responsible for breaking a family history of spanking and the belt on my husband’s side of the family. I can attest to the anguish, effort and determination it takes both to react differently to the parenting I received and also to offer myself enough empathy where I fail to meet my own expectations to not fall into repeating patterns as I am beyond being able to change it.

  4. avatar Margaret Cordill says:

    I do not spank as a parent BECAUSE I was spanked as a child. I vowed to never do it.

  5. I was raised in a family where spanking was used as discipline for perceived disobedience or irresponsibilty.
    “Discipline” comes from the latin “discipulus” or pupil, so therefore the act of spanking was to teach me that my behaviors would bring me pain/shame. Therefore, my goal was to not be disobedient or irresponsible, or at least, to not get caught doing so.
    Once I had a child, I tried to discipline in the mold of my parents. After one spank to my small daughter, I just knew, mentally and viscerally that what I was doing was wrong. I apologized and promised to never do it again.
    Styles of parenting are epigenetic and breaking free of a negative cycle is a hard-earned and worthy purpose. It required me to seek out new methods, educate myself, and attempt to educate those around me. I feel sure-footed and confidant in my parenting style now and hope that the work I’ve done will reap benefits for my relationship with my children in the future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More From Janet

Books & Recommendations