Random Thoughts On “Beyond Bottles And Breasts” (My Previous Post)

One thing I have felt across-the-board with all the stories about breast and bottle feeding is that we are all doing the very best we can. We can all agree that the experience of parenting an infant is not easy, whether it’s your first or fifth child.  There are extreme highs and lows (usually depending upon how much sleep you’ve had), from ecstasy to hopelessness. I have been there. We make choices based on philosophy, convenience, conventional wisdom, and instinct.

At the end of the day, everyone is trying to be the best parent possible, and that’s why I have so much empathy for those that feel judged. I have felt judged. Oh, boy, have I felt judged (see Big Bad Mama). But I do think we should be as well-informed about parenting choices as possible before deciding what works for us.

I believe the idea that babies are best comforted by keeping a nipple (of any kind) in their mouths is a misconception that can make breastfeeding needlessly daunting. We are all so afraid of the tears. I agree they go straight to the heart and are impossible to hear, but how is a baby ever going feel comfortable with his feelings if his parents aren’t?

There’s a reason I was able to breastfeed 3 children and give them one-on-one time while I nursed: I allowed them to cry sometimes. When they were uncomfortable for reasons besides hunger, I tried to find out what they needed. Sometimes they just needed the release of crying. I didn’t run off and leave them. I stayed with them, but tried to calm myself and allow them to cry when they seemed to need that. If an older child wanted me for something while I was nursing the baby, they had to wait. Sometimes they cried, but they knew they would get focused time with me later.

I also allowed my babies time to move freely in a safe cozy place while I watched them, did chores, or just took a break. I learned that infants need lots of time and space to initiate their own activities and think their own thoughts. They need time to stretch, explore their hands and feet, twist, gaze at shadows or whatever else they choose, and reach for simple toys we place near them. Infants want to begin exploring the world on their terms, not always be a passenger to whatever parents are doing. Watching what they do, discovering and appreciating their unique personalities are rewards for our hard work.

Babies get used to whatever we do with them, so if they are used to our constant carrying, then they don’t know what they are missing, and they just want more carrying. If I carried and fed a baby all day for comfort; if I showed babies my world all the time rather than allowing them to discover theirs, I would have to multi-task while I fed, I suppose.

I may be an idealist, but I’m no martyr. In fact, I’m quite lazy. I just believe in different priorities for babies (and for moms, too). I’ve seen that babies are capable of exploring, thinking, having their own interests, self-learning, and expressing their feelings just like adults.  They also deserve a loved one’s attention when they are physically close, just the way adults do.

I present this point-of-view as an option to be considered. It is time-tested and research-supported. It isn’t always easier in the short term, but it is much easier in the long-term. It makes life easier for parent and child because it helps your baby becomes the secure, inner-directed, emotionally expressive, capable, and self-confident person he or she was born to be. But there are lots of good ways to raise babies. Let’s continue to share what we know and support each other.

For more context, please read Beyond Bottles And Breasts – The Key To Whole Baby Nourishment,  especially the Comments section.


Please share your comments and questions. I read them all and respond to as many as time will allow.

  1. Dearest Janet,

    The last thing in the world you are is “lazy!” The work you put into defining and explaining this seemingly straightforward and simple philosophy ALONE is amazing! And the RIE Approach itself is, as you say, NOT easy in the short term…in fact, it’s much harder and more time consuming, but the results are outstanding…as are the results of this blog. Thank you for taking the time to put yourself, and RIE, out there.

  2. I really like this post. its v reassuring as it resonates with my instincts + my experience with my boy(v nearly 1 yr old). A lot of my friends baby-carry + nearly everyone i know breastfeeds. i havent found either thing works for us. the bf because by the time he worked out how to latch on my milk flow had almost dried up + its never really recovered. i express milk for him + top up with formula. no-one has actually said im a slacker but theyre all into tne natural parenting thing, + i feel inadequate when they go ON about how great boobs are. The other issue is the sling business. i discovered all this stuff quite late, maybe when he was 5 mths old, + didnt try slings til after that. He hates it if hes restrained for more than 10 mins. He wants to be free! He loves his buggy where he can see whats happening. The big thing for me is listening to him. He really enjoys his playtimes + is great at independant play (i think it was you posted the baby interrupted stuff) + he knows if he squeaks me or dad will b there. He tells me v clearly when hes full up either from bottle or his solids, when hes tired, when he wants to play, etc etc. I feel that we have a good secure understanding relationship. I just find it hard when everyone else i know does things differently from me. It makes me doubt my own judgement. But writing this out clearly has made me realise its all good! So thanks v much for sparking it off. I do have other things id like to ask but lil man needs me. til the next time!! xxx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More From Janet

Books & Recommendations